top of page

The Best Pizza in the Treasure Valley, ID (2024)

Updated: Feb 12

One of my family's favorite exhibits at the Children's Museum of Idaho is the Idaho Pizza Company's little pretend pizza restaurant. The kids love making their own pizzas and I love the chance to sit down and pretend to order from the cute wait staff. But every single time we enjoy this area I leave craving pizza! You too? 

cheese pizza in a box with one piece being pulled away

Well the other day our family grabbed some pizza from Idaho Pizza Company and I asked on Instagram what your family's favorite places to get the best pizza take out was across the Treasure Valley. I rounded up all the answers below! Prepare to be hungry... 

Whether you're looking for a great option for the whole family, something delivered to your front door, neapolitan-style pizza or deep dish, this list of delicious pizza will delight your taste buds!

🍕Here were the 10 most popular pizza restaurants 🍕

-Idaho Pizza Company-

Location: There are 12 in the Treasure Valley! Check this link for locations. 

About: "Idaho Pizza Company is a local franchise that has been serving Idaho for over 20 years. With our family friendly casual atmosphere, it's the perfect place to gather with friends, family or your little league team after the game. Offering great pizza, award winning salad bar, sandwiches, and starters there's something for everyone. Whether it's dine-in, delivery, or carry-out, Idaho Pizza Company has a great dining experience waiting for you to enjoy. So come by or give us a call at any one of our 16 convenient locations. Idaho Pizza Company, 'As Good as the Great Outdoors!'." This was hands down the Boise locals' top pizza place!

-Flying Pie-

Location: There are 7! Check this link for locations.

About: "Launched as a pie in the sky idea in 1978, Flying Pie is now a much beloved homegrown institution, with hot spots in Boise, Meridian and Nampa. Our pizzas may go in a box, but we think outside of it (and inside of it too, of course, because that’s where the delicious lives). This out-of-the-box mindset has made us whirled famous." They really do have a variety of awesome pizzas!

-The Wylder-

Location: 501 West Broad Street, Boise, Idaho 

About: "Damn good pizza, craft cocktails, & nightly suppers. We make hand crafted, slow batch pizza with soul. Full service dining, craft cocktails, and suppers." The crispy pepperoni pizza is my husband's all time favorite and we LOVE pizza!


Location: 12375 W Chinden Blvd STE G, Boise, ID 83713 and 235 N 5th St, Boise, ID 83702 

About: "Original New York style pizza." This one is probably one of the best places to get that classic New York style in the Treasure Valley!

-Uncle Bob's-

Location: 1728 E McMillan RD STE 100

About: "We want to make sure we offer something great for everyone. We have crafted a menu that all members of the family will love. We have a game room for the kids and a great beer and wine selection for mom and dad. With TVs surrounding the entire dining room, we have made sure that every game can be enjoyed all year round. We pride ourselves on our family culture, and can’t wait to welcome you to our UB family!" We love that they have such a casual setting for families to enjoy!

-Johnny Bronx-

Location: 4970 N Linder RdMeridian, ID 83646 and 150 S Ten Mile Rd #100 Meridian, ID 83642

About: "At Johnny Bronx, the proof is in the dough. Our pizza is better for a reason. We use only the freshest ingredients and our dough is scratch made in house. We even filter the water to give you just the right balance and mineral content as NY water." 


Location: 4865 N Ten Mile Rd, Meridian, ID 83646

About: "Naturally, our love of making great pizza started back in the Old World, where our founder, Pasquale “Pat” Giammarco, learned the importance of doing things the right way. Obsess over the details. Take pride in what you make. Appreciate the best things in life—like Ah!thentic® Italian pizza! When he was nine years old, he moved with his family from Sulmona, Italy, to America, and he brought with him a dedication to never cutting corners. Pat founded Marco’s Pizza in 1978, and he’s been cutting delicious slices ever since."


Location: 304 S Americana, Boise, ID 83702, United States 

About: "New York style pizza with vegan options." (Honestly it's the lack of description that makes it most intriguing to me! Also their Instagram is hilarious!)


Location: 8489 W Overland RdBoise, ID 83709 and 11200 W Hercules Dr #102 Star, ID 83669

About: "We, the pizza-loving people of Westside Pizza, do solemnly swear to faithfully execute what it means to be “All About The Pizza” with every breath we take.

We promise to prepare, bake and serve our delicious hand-crafted pizzas, made from freshly-made dough, sauce made from plump vine-ripened California tomatoes, savory authentic meats and freshly-grated mozzarella. We do this for the love of pizza, and if you share the same level of dedication then you’ll appreciate all the quality we bake into every yummy bite. And we’re not just saying this. You’ve got our word on it."

-Red Bench-

Location: 1204 S. Vista Ave Boise, ID 83705 

About: "From the creators of Idaho focused farm to table restaurant Juniper Kitchen and Cocktails, Red Bench Pizza showcases old world, Neapolitan style pizza in the heart of the Boise, Idaho. Our menu is crafted using made from scratch recipes with fresh, quality ingredients. Other options rely on preservatives and fillers to live that cardboard box life. We don't use tricks."

Other popular pizza spots in the Boise area:

Lulu's Fine Pizza (and Sushi) (we frequent the one off N Bogus Basin Rd - as do lots of skiers on their way down from Bogus!)

North End Pizza Co (Hyde Park)


Pie Hole (we love the one on N 8th St - in the heart of downtown Boise)

Extreme Pizza



Mountain Mike's

Alpine (sourdough crust!)



Smoky Mountain Pizzeria Grill (You can get discounted gift cards at Costco!)




Papa Murphy's (a popular spot for take and bake pizza)

Spitfire Craft Pizza

Black Moon (Garden City)

Chicago Connection

Old Chicago

I propose a pizza tour of Boise! You in?

*Save this list for the next time you're craving a good old slice of 'za!*


bottom of page